But even if it does, the next devastating, yetunnamed outbreak is not so much a matter of if but when. The standing committee on finance met with the south african revenue service sars for a briefing on the makwakwa matter as well as the sars and kpmg report on allegations against the sars intelligence unit. How kpmgs rogue unit report was ludicrous from the. International auditing firm kpmg says it has offered to pay back sars r23 million for a report it compiled into the socalled spy unit or to make a donation for the same amount to charity. While kpmg sa might have withdrawn the findings and conclusions of a controversial forensic report into an alleged covert unit in sars as well as offered to reimburse the r23million it was. International auditing firm kpmg has withdrawn all of its findings recommendations and conclusions around its report into the south african. Ordinarily we would not choose to respond in the media on a confidential assignment but we are concerned that certain aspects of our. Sep 18, 2017 moyane clings to existence of socalled rogue unit despite kpmg confession. The meetings were over the damage the findings conclusions and recommendations of kpmgs report into the alleged sars rogue unit had caused. Johannesburg audit firm kpmg must realise the extent of the damage that their report on the socalled rogue unit at the south african revenue service sars has caused to the country. Read a march 2020 report pdf 103 kb prepared by the kpmg member firm in south africa. Kpmg withdraws findings on sars rogue unit, apologises to. The south african revenue service sars would neither confirm nor deny that kpmg south africa has paid back the r23million it received as.
Sep 18, 2017 sars notes the media statement which was issued by kpmg international on the 15 september 2017. Exsars man blasts kpmg over rogue unit report in a scathing legal attack one of the socalled sars rogue unit members johan van loggerenberg has accused international auditing firm kpmg of suppressing evidence of criminal offences, notes a timeslive report. Sep 27, 2017 what the south african kpmg saga says about shareholder activism. Kpmg international has announced that it will launch a full, independent investigation into its south african branchs dealings with the gupta family, and its involvement with the sars report. This report was seen by elements of the media to be part of a wider guptalinked state capture conspiracy, with the aim of forcing gordhan out. Sep 15, 2017 kpmg withdraws findings on sars rogue unit, apologises to gordhan as nine execs resign. Sep 18, 2017 the south african revenue services briefs the media on the withdrawal of sars report by kpmg. The gupta effectcartoon printedused with permission from media query johann van loggerenberg kpmg sars report we confirm that we act for mr jh van loggerenberg our client and refer to your email dated 4 october 2017 and the questions contained therein. Rights sars prior to amendment2 to section 172 of the incometax act, 1961 the act is not taxable as a perquisite. Ntsebeza inquiry gets final sars rogue unit report from kpmg fin24. Rogue sars unit was real, and was spying on taxpayers. Meanwhile, sars commissioner tom moyane has in september insisted that kpmg was not flawed. Sars established and administered a covert and rogue intelligence unit in contravention of the law. Read a february 2020 report pdf 539 kb prepared by the kpmg member firm in south africa.
Sep 27, 2017 former sars official lambastes kpmg for its dodgy sars report. Depositswhether an amount received is indeed a deposit and, if so, what is the vat treatment when such deposit is forfeited or applied as consideration for the supply of goods or services. Gordhan lashes kpmg sars report withdrawal moneyweb. Kpmg report compromised by interference, undeclared conflicts of interest and press leaks. The inside story of sarss elite crimebusting unit shows the report was full of laughable findings. The south african revenue service sars will on monday host a media conference dealing with the withdrawal by kpmg of its sars report. Gordhan lashes kpmg sars report withdrawal it is unfortunate that a company with the stature of kpmg has been found to be wanting. A new report by kpmg has confirmed that the rogue sars spy unit was real, and that it was spying on south africans and operating outside the law. Its possible that the coronavirus threat will eventually fade, as the ebola, zika, and severe acute respiratory syndrome sars viruses have in recent years. What the south african kpmg saga says about shareholder activism. Kpmg report was delivered to sars in late 2015 and was only made final on the january 26 2016.
Kpmg may have thus also become a possible enabler of illicit capital flows in the process. Ceo of sars, mr tom moyane moyane, in relation to a report of the fic. Sars guns for kpmg over rogue unit report calls for. Sars notes the media statement which was issued by kpmg international on the 15 september 2017. The report made headlines when a version of it was leaked to the media in late 2015. The statement includes kpmg internationals action pertaining to among other things, the setting aside of the conclusions and recommendations of the allegations of irregular and misconduct report, report.
Sars plans legal action against kpmg for reputational damage. While kpmg sa might have withdrawn the findings and conclusions of a controversial forensic report into an alleged covert unit in sars as well. In 2015, kpmg issued a controversial report that implicated former finance minister pravin gordhan in the creation of an illegal intelligence gathering unit of the south african revenue service sars. This is one of our original reports which prove kpmg and sars conspired against the rogue unit, from 18 months ago. The second discussion dealt with sars and kpmg report on allegations against the sars intelligence unit. The first one is that we are going to institute legal proceedings against kpmg for reputational damage to sars. It investigated an intelligence unit within the revenue service that had, as news24 previously reported, started to investigate highprofile tax offenders. No legal expertise to back up sars report conclusions.
The draft findings in the leaked report which two highly placed sources both within and close to sars told city press have been included in the final kpmg document include that. The south african revenue services briefs the media on the withdrawal of sars report by kpmg. The business implications of coronavirus kpmg india. The south african revenue service sars has thus far indicated that no. The kpmg sars report has received considerable exposure in the media which should never have occurred as the work was being conducted under strict rules of confidentiality which were clearly articulated in our letter of engagement as well as in our findings. How kpmgs rogue unit report was ludicrous from the beginning this extract from rogue. Feb 04, 2018 the south african revenue service sars would neither confirm nor deny that kpmg south africa has paid back the r23million it received as payment for its report on the socalled rogue unit. Nhlamu dlomu, new kpmg ceo kpmg is being probed for the work it did for the guptaowned linkway trading as well as for bungling a forensic report a rogue unit operating at sars.
Vat considerations, coronavirus kpmg united states. Get the latest kpmg thought leadership directly to your individual personalised dashboard register now login. Read a march 2020 report pdf 329 kb prepared by the kpmg member firm in south africa. Kpmg and the independent regulatory board for auditors irba were also in attendance. Read an april 2020 report pdf 487 kb prepared by the kpmg. Kpmg publicly withdrew the conclusions of the report in september 2017, saying it regretted the impact the report had.
Kpmg transformation survey business transformation and. Kpmg must realise damage its sars report caused sa, says. On friday, kpmg south africa appointed nhlamu dlomu as its new. With regards to the sars report, we have explained in detail in the past, and most recently at the ntsebeza inquiry, the genesis of the sars. Sep 27, 2017 another charge levelled against kpmg relates to a problematic report produced by the firm for south african revenue service sars. Sars commissioner tom moyane has called auditing firm kpmgs withdrawal of a controversial report into the socalled rogue sars unit an attempt to discredit the tax agency and paint it as.
Kpmg report on sars rogue unit free ebook download as pdf file. Inside story of how kpmg did the devils work at sars. The second one is that we are going to report kpmg to audit statutory. Former sars official lambastes kpmg for its dodgy sars report. We confirm that we act for mr jh van loggerenberg our. Since there is currently no other guidance on financial transactions from a south african perspective, tax professionals expected that south african revenue service will adopt the guidance set out in the new chapter x of the oecd transfer pricing guidelines. Sars wont confirm whether kpmg sa paid back r23m for its. The report claimed that a rogue spy unit was operating within sars, which led to the removal of finance minister pravin gordhan, on the grounds that he should have known about or was involved with the rogue unit. Sars commissioner tom moyane has called auditing firm kpmgs withdrawal of a controversial report into the socalled rogue sars unit an attempt to.
With regards to the sars report, we have explained in detail in the past, and most recently at the ntsebeza inquiry, the genesis of the sars report, the nature of the work done, sources of information used, key decisions taken, timing of drafts and the. Sep 22, 2017 kpmg international has announced that it will launch a full, independent investigation into its south african branchs dealings with the gupta family, and its involvement with the sars report. International auditing firm kpmg has withdrawn all of its findings recommendations and conclusions around its report into the south african revenue service sars rogue. Ntsebeza inquiry gets final sars rogue unit report from kpmg.
Last week kpmg announced that it had withdrawn its report on the work the audit firm did for sars and on behalf of the gupta family. On friday, kpmg south africa appointed nhlamu dlomu as its new chief executive. Moyane said that the kpmg report is the exclusive property of sars and that kpmg had broken its contractual obligations to the revenue service when it agreed to investigate the socalled. The report was partly responsible for the downfall of former finance minister pravin gordhan, who was accused of having known about and. Sars spokesman sandile memela and kpmg spokesman nqubeko sibiya both asked for queries to be sent by email when contacted for comment on their mobile phones on sunday. The press conference will take place at the sars offices in pretoria. Kpmg slammed by south africas pravin gordhan on tax report. About the survey for this report, kpmg china, hsbc and hkgcc commissioned yougov to conduct a survey of 747 business executives in mainland china, hong kong and macau. International auditing firm kpmg has withdrawn all of its findings recommendations and conclusions around its report into the south african revenue service sars rogue spy unit. Kpmg to launch full independent investigation into gupta.
Sep 20, 2017 on monday morning sars and its commissioner, tom moyane, publicly criticised, rebuked and attacked the auditing firm kpmg for repudiating its own report on what we could now call the nonrogue unit at sars. Kpmg withdraws findings on sars rogue unit, apologises. Kpmg cans sars rogue unit report apologises to gordhan. Sars established and administered a covert and rogue intelligence unit in.
The report was partly responsible for the downfall of former finance minister pravin gordhan, who was accused of having. Former sars official johan van loggerenberg lambastes kpmg for its dodgy sars report. Oct 03, 2017 while kpmg sa might have withdrawn the findings and conclusions of a controversial forensic report into an alleged covert unit in sars as well as offered to reimburse the r23million it was. Sep 15, 2017 international auditing firm kpmg has withdrawn all of its findings recommendations and conclusions around its report into the south african revenue service sars rogue spy unit. Audit firm kpmg must realise the extent of the damage that their report on the socalled rogue unit at the south african revenue service sars has caused to the country, future south africa. Sep 15, 2017 gordhan lashes kpmg sars report withdrawal it is unfortunate that a company with the stature of kpmg has been found to be wanting. Kpmg rocked by south african corruption scandal accountancy age. The report was authored by kpmg and requested by sars commissioner tom moyane. Sars plans legal action against kpmg for reputational damage we will also report the firm to various authoritative bodies and to the finance minister luther lebelo. Also, work kpmg was currently performing for sars should be seized and all work conducted by the firm in the past 10 years should also be assessed with the aim to determine whether there was a value for money and whether sars should demand its money back, report kpmg to parliament through scopa and scof with the aim to investigate the. What the south african kpmg saga says about shareholder.
69 58 876 671 1460 1155 736 834 1244 919 536 1296 1228 170 1315 1334 1456 338 375 930 677 504 652 490 1448 611 375 1138 71 1092 651 1390